Turkey Order Form

Our turkeys are minimally processed with no additives or preservatives added at the time of processing. Other turkeys are often injected with a salt & oil solution during processing which is supposed to make them more tender and flavorful. We don’t agree. We think this simply adds water weight to the turkey and allows the turkey to dry out while cooking. It also adds sodium and fat to an otherwise healthy meat.

We are sold out of our cooked and sliced turkey and turkey dinners, Turduckens and Smoked Turkey. You can still order our extremely popular, juicy and healthy Fresh Turkeys, though we are sold out of some sizes.

    Pickup for items ordered is Monday, November 25th through Wednesday, November 27th. We are open from 8 A.M. to 6 P. M. If you are not picking up on Monday-Wednesday before Thanksgiving, please let us know in your comment.

    Fresh Turkey

    What size turkey do I order? The rule of Thumb on turkey size is 1 pound to 1-1/4 pound per adult person. As the turkey size gets larger, you will be able to serve more people per pound. This will allow for some leftovers. If you want more leftovers, then you should order a larger turkey. The same rule of thumb is true for Turkey Breasts.

    Fresh Hen Turkeys - $2.59lb

    Fresh Tom Turkey - $2.59lb

    Fresh Turkey Breast - $4.89lb


    McGonigle's cooks its fresh turkeys in our own kitchen. We sell it by the pound either mixed dark and white meat or all white meat. It is sliced in a pan and ready to pop right into your oven. No Slicing, no mess, just heating.

    White and Dark Roasted, Sliced Turkey - $11.98lb

    All White Roasted, Sliced Turkey - $14.99lb
    Complete Thanksgiving Day Turkey Dinner

    Each meal includes our Fresh Turkey, roasted, sliced and placed in a pan, Mashed Potatoes, Herb Stuffing, Homestyle Green Beans, Gravy, Cranberry Walnut Relish, Rolls and Butter. You have your choice of ordering your dinner with a proportional mix of white and dark meat, or you have the choice of all white meat. Don't forget to order one of our delicious pies for Dessert

    Dinners with White and Dark Turkey

    Dinners with All White Turkey

    Burger's Smoked Turkey - $4.99 lb

    Add some extras to your Thanksgiving Dinner Order

    Fresh Oysters - $18.99 lb

    Oysters add a distinctly rich flavor to your holiday meal. Click Here for our famous Oyster Stuffing Recipe


    Quantities Limited - Available in-store upon pickup while supplies last

    • Pt Fresh Mashed Potatoes $3.49pt – serves 2-4 people
    • Qt Homestyle Green Beans $6.99qt – serves 4-6 people
    • Qt Savory Herb Dressing $6.99qt – serves 4-6 people
    • Pt Homemade Turkey Gravy $4.99pt – serves 4-6 people
    • Pt Homemade Cranberry Walnut Relish $4.98pt


    Make your Thanksgiving Day easy with our homemade side dishes. We have taken all the orders of side dishes that we are positive we can fill. There will be extra available, but on a first come, first serve basis.

    Don't Forget Dessert!!

    Quantities Limited - Available in-store upon pickup while supplies last

    Our Pecan Pie and our Sour Cream Apple Pie are made here in our own kitchen. Our Pumpkin Pie is made especially for us by a local bakery.

    Your Information

    Note: Please do not ask us to cook this turkey. If you want cooked turkey, go back and order from the cooked turkey order page.

    Thank you!!! See you on Tuesday, Nov. 24th or Wednesday, Nov. 25th!!!

    Please wait...